Kash Patel’s Atlantic lawsuit is not designed to win — it’s meant to intimidate

Kash Patel’s Atlantic lawsuit is not designed to win — it’s meant to intimidate

Kash Patel’s $250 million defamation suit against The Atlantic is, to put it mildly, a long shot. The article painted a portrait of an FBI director who engaged in excessive drinking and relatively minimal work. Patel’s suit says it aims to hold the publication “accountable for a sweeping, malicious, and defamatory hit piece,” alleging the journalists’ “crossed the legal line by publishing an article replete with false and obviously fabricated allegations designed to destroy Director Patel’s reputation.” The Atlantic said it stands by its reporting, calling the suit “meritless.”

Patel’s only chance to win on this claim is to prove the alleged defamatory statements were false, that they harmed his reputation and, because Patel is a public figure, that they were made with “actual malice.” Proving actual malice requires evidence that Atlantic journalists knew they published false statements about Patel or acted in reckless disregard of whether the statements were true or false. This is a high standard requiring much more than negligence, which demands only that the outlet’s editors and reporters should have known that certain statements were false.  

Why do we demand that public figures prove actual malice while private figures only need to show negligence? Three words: the First Amendment. 

Play

Michael Steele: ‘Hella high’ bar for Kash Patel to prove defamation against The Atlantic

April 20, 2026 / 07:02

Back in 1964, a unanimous Supreme Court held in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan that public officials suing for defamation must satisfy this more exacting standard, because anything less would infringe on our speech rights. (Three years later, the Supreme Court extended this standard to include public figures). Public figures are generally

Original

Shreveport mass shooting demands that we talk about more than mental illness

Four days after Virginia police say former Virginia Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax murdered his wife, Cerina Fairfax, and killed himself, police in Shreveport, Louisiana, say a former National Guardsman shot his wife and a woman who’s been described as his girlfriend and fatally shot eight children. Seven of the children Shamar Elkins killed were his own, those Louisiana authorities say, and the eighth was a cousin of the other seven. Elkins died after police pursued him, and it remains unclear whether he killed himself or was killed by police.

The two awful crimes have prompted a debate about mental illness and what role it may have played.

The two awful crimes have prompted a debate about mental illness and what role it may have played in these two men reportedly killing — and trying to kill — people so close to them. But if nothing else, the past week’s headlines should remind us of this chilling reality: For millennia, a global culture of patriarchal dominance and violence has caused women to suffer and die. Among the many harrowing statistics in UN Women’s “Progress on the Sustainable Development Goals: The gender snapshot 2025” was this one: Worldwide, 50,000 women and girls were killed by intimate partners or family members — almost all of them men — in 2024. That was 60% of all the women and girls who died of homicide that year.

That means that across the world in 2024, almost every 10 minutes, a woman’s life was taken by someone she knew intimately, and most likely loved. That statistic stands in stark contrast to the 11% of male homicide victims who were

Original

Trump’s choice of passage for a Bible-reading event is teeming with irony

Trump’s choice of passage for a Bible-reading event is teeming with irony

A video of President Donald Trump reading a Bible passage in the Oval Office will be aired Tuesday night as part of a marathon Bible reading organized by a coalition of far-right Christian groups. Officially, “America Reads the Bible” is part of the coalition’s events celebrating the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence in July. Unofficially, the timing is propitious, coming days after Trump attacked Pope Leo XIV and sparked backlash by posting a (now deleted) artificial intelligence-generated image of himself depicted as Jesus Christ.

The list of readers includes many high-profile participants, among them Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth (who recently adapted a monologue from “Pulp Fiction” in place of a real Bible verse). As the president, though, Trump almost certainly had his pick of the entire book. And his choice of passage reflects the essence of his appeal to Christians: not piety, but power.

Trump will read 2 Chronicles 7:11-22, in which God tells the ancient Israelites:

If My people, which are called by my name, shall humble themselves, and pray, and seek my face, and turn from their wicked ways; then will I hear from heaven, and will forgive their sin, and will heal their land.

This passage is a favorite of Christian nationalists, who falsely portray the United States as being founded to be God’s new spiritual and political home. They love this passage because it frames national renewal as a matter of spiritual performance. It is a theology of restoration that conveniently asks nothing about who has been excluded from the land, who built it and who still isn’t

Original

Why MAGA has developed conspiracy theories about the assassination attempt on Trump

Why MAGA has developed conspiracy theories about the assassination attempt on Trump

Over the weekend, former Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., published multiple posts on X questioning authorities’ accounts of the July 2024 attempted assassination of then-presidential candidate Donald Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania.

Greene said Trump won’t “release the information” about the would-be assassin, Thomas Crooks, and accused the president of a “cover up.” She suggested without evidence that Crooks acted in concert with others who have yet to be identified, and asked why Trump has failed to cracked down on them. She boosted a post by a delegate from Texas during the 2024 Republican National Convention, who put scare quotes around the term “assassination attempt” when describing her questions about what happened in Butler that summer day and described his “fight, fight, fight” photo as suspiciously polished.

It can’t be that Trump lied to them or has no principles, it must be a conspiracy.

Greene is, of course, a seasoned conspiracy theorist, so her posts aren’t exactly surprising. But what’s striking is how she’s advancing a trend: right-wing critics of Trump floating unsubstantiated conspiracy theories about the Butler assassination attempt — sometimes suggesting that Trump himself may have staged the event. As Trump alienates elements of his right-wing base, he’s at risk of being engulfed by the kind of conspiratorial worldview he once commanded to his own advantage.

Several other right-leaning commentators and political figures have floated conspiracy theories about Butler. Tim Dillon, a comedian and podcaster who has supported Trump and helped build support for him among young men, said earlier in April, “I think [Trump] should admit” that he staged his own assassination attempt. In November, Tucker Carlson said the

Original

Virginia’s flat arguments for gerrymandering show a problem for Democrats

Virginia’s flat arguments for gerrymandering show a problem for Democrats

Voters heading to the polls in Virginia on Tuesday may determine the outcome of the November elections for the rest of the country.

They will decide whether the state should redraw its congressional districts to boost the number of Democrats in the House. The ballot measure is intended to counter Republican gerrymandering in other states, which was encouraged by Donald Trump to maintain GOP control of the House despite sagging polls.

Most of us learned in social studies class that gerrymandering is an inherently corrupt activity that robs voters of the opportunity of legitimate choices. Allowing politicians to draw their own district lines is like letting teenagers set their own curfews — an inherent conflict of interest that will almost always turn out badly.

So the challenge facing Virginia Democrats has been convincing the electorate that doing a bad thing to stop a worse thing is actually a good thing. That’s a tough message to sell, but Democrats only made their own job harder.

The measure’s backers seem to have resigned themselves to a hesitant and often ambivalent message. They readily admit that gerrymandering is an intentional subversion of the voters’ will, but tentatively argue that employing Trumpy methods to defeat Trump will lead to a less Trumpy outcome. They rend their garments in public, which leads to a less-than-convincing battle cry.

“Nobody wants to do this. I don’t want to do this,” said one Democratic legislator. “[But] we can’t sit back and wait.”

“I believe that people should choose their representatives. Representatives shouldn’t choose their people,” lamented another. “We’ve been pushed into a situation not of our own choosing.”

Neither of those quotes would work on a bumper sticker or

Original

Justice Department spurns French probe into Elon Musk and X

The Trump administration said it won’t help French authorities to investigate Elon Musk and his scandal-plagued social media platform, X.

On Friday, The Wall Street Journal reported on a letter, which hasn’t been reviewed by MS NOW, in which the Trump Department of Justice told French officials it isn’t going to get involved in their efforts to investigate Musk and X. Per the Journal:

‘This investigation seeks to use the criminal legal system in France to regulate a public square for the free expression of ideas and opinions in a manner contrary to the First Amendment of the United States Constitution,’ said the letter, reviewed by The Wall Street Journal. The letter also said France’s requests for U.S. assistance ‘constitute an effort to entangle the United States in a politically charged criminal proceeding aimed at wrongfully regulating through prosecution the business activities of a social media platform.’

The department confirmed to the Journal it sent the letter. 

France launched an investigation into X last fall after the platform’s chatbot, Grok, responded to users by promoting holocaust denial. At the time, French investigators also raised concerns about foreign influence campaigns on the platform. And in February, following a scandal in which users prompted Grok to generate nonconsensual pornographic images, including images appearing to depict children, French authorities raided X’s offices and summoned Musk for questioning. 

Trump’s administration has previously threatened British investigators for its own probe into the Grok porn scandal.

The administration has given itself a pretext to insulate Musk and his platform from accountability by portraying them as integral to the projection of democracy abroad. Trump’s State Department has touted Musk’s platform as a tool to

Original